Integrity Employee Leasing announces leadership promotions
Integrity Employee Leasing, one of the country’s fastest-growing Professional Employer Organization (PEO) companies, has announced the promotions of Erin Natoli and Jayme “Jay” Waters to vice presidents of operations.
Natoli joined Integrity Employee Leasing in 2016 as a workers’ compensation specialist before advancing to risk manager in 2019, and she recently recognized a decade of service with the company. In her new role as vice president of operations, Natoli will lead finance functions and will report to and partner with the CEO, chief financial officer (CFO) and chairman of the board on the company’s financial performance, planning and operations. Through financial analysis efforts, Natoli will assist the company’s C-suite team in future expansion efforts while enhancing Integrity’s Florida operations. Additionally, she will establish and own processes and schedules to strengthen accountability and controls and will partner across operations leadership to align on goals, leadership and day-to-day business operations.
Waters joined the company in 2018 as a business consultant and was promoted to sales director in 2019. As vice president of operations, she will lead operational and revenue-planning initiatives that prioritize sustainable growth, service quality, cost control and strengthen cross-department execution. Similarly, she will provide executive oversight across payroll, human resources, client services, accounting, reporting, workers’ compensation, technology and sales. Waters will collaborate with senior leadership to establish company priorities, clarify decision-making authority and translate organization goals into practical expectations for teams, and she will be responsible for evaluating workflows, staffing structures and add-on services for workload management and client profitability. She will also guide employee relations and performance matters and will develop company-wide communications, management standards, internal programs and policies that reinforce clarity, consistency and organizational culture.
In their new roles, Waters and Natoli will oversee day-to-day operations, enabling CEO Robert Hensley and chief financial officer Chris Naylon to prioritize company growth and expansion efforts.
“Over the last near-decade, Erin and Jay have demonstrated exceptional leadership, growth and dedication to not just Integrity Employee Leasing, but to the hundreds of clients we serve nationwide,” said Hensley, president and CEO of Integrity Employee Leasing. “Being a leader in the industry does not just mean you excel at your role – it means that you are a trusted teammate, innovative and solution-driven, characteristics that both Erin and Jay exemplify to the highest degree.”
A graduate of Port Charlotte High School and a Charlotte County native, Natoli joined Integrity Employee Leasing directly after high school. In her time with the company, she has been named to Charlotte County Economic Development’s 40 Under 40 list for her professional leadership and community involvement and has earned her Florida 2-20 General Lines Insurance Agent License. In 2021, Natoli helped launch the company’s charitable arm, the Integrity Charitable Foundation, which provides financial support to local nonprofit organizations that positively influence Southwest Florida.
Waters, a fellow Charlotte County native, was named by both Business Observer and Charlotte County Economic Development as a 40 Under 40 honoree in 2022 and 2025, respectively. Currently, Waters serves as president of the Integrity Charitable Foundation and is a member of the Charlotte County Chamber of Commerce’s Leadership Charlotte program.
Natoli and Waters have both recently obtained their Controlling Person’s Licenses for the State of Florida, which strengthens the company’s regulatory standing and positions the company for continued growth in the Florida market.
For more information on Integrity Employee Leasing, visit IntegrityEL.com.
About Integrity Employee Leasing
Integrity Employee Leasing, based in Port Charlotte, is a full-service Professional Employer Organization (PEO), specializing in offering superior customer service to companies of all sizes. Integrity partners with companies and allows them to focus on running a successful business by handling the day-to-day administrative services needed. These services include payroll administration, human resources, bookkeeping, insurance products and more. The owners of Integrity bring over 20 years’ experience in the PEO industry with a trained staff ready to satisfy all employee and human resource needs. In addition to offering excellent customer service, Integrity is poised to be extremely competitive due to an emphasis on risk management and cost controls. Because of dedication to personal, prompt and accurate service, Integrity Employee Leasing is one of the fastest-growing PEO companies in the nation, dedicated to honesty and fairness for clients, employees, agents and vendors. For information, visit IntegrityEL.com.
